فهرست مطالب
فصلنامه علوم حدیث
سال بیستم شماره 3 (پیاپی 77، پاییز 1394)
- تاریخ انتشار: 1394/12/15
- تعداد عناوین: 8
-
-
صفحات 3-27
-
صفحات 28-58
-
صفحات 81-103
-
صفحات 104-134
-
صفحات 183-188
-
Pages 3-27Fasting on the Day of Ashura has constantly been under attention of Sunni scholars, and at the same time has been a controversial discussion among the Shia scholars. The cause of this difference was the existence of two groups of traditions in Shia hadith literature about this subject. This article intends to examine the isnâd (transmission chain) of these traditions and cast a glance at the content of them in a descriptive analytical-critical method with the purpose of familiarity with these two groups of traditions,and to verify their validity.
The findings of the present research denote that the fasting on the Day of Ashura had prevailed before the fast of Ramadan was legislated, but it was forsaken later.
Some of the traditions forbidding the fasting on the Day of Ashura are weak from the aspect of transmission chain, however, they collectively seem stronger than the traditions that permit this fasting, and conform better with the reported sîrah (conduct) of the Imams after the heart-rending Event of Ashura. Furthermore, the fact that Shakh Kulaynî contented himself with merely narrating the permitting traditions, can be deemed an evidence for the validity decrease of permitting traditions in his opinion.Keywords: sawm, fasting, Ashura, Shia, traditions, types, isnads, purport of opinions -
Pages 28-58There exist traditions in hadith texts speaking of presenting the tawîlî (interpretative) traditions to the Book of God. These traditions are considered as suggesting a strategy and a criterion, also accepted by Islamic scholars, to verify the authenticity of traditions.
On the other hand, there exist in the Islamic literatures, traditions containing teachings called tawîl (interpretation), and it is of the bâṭinî (esoteric) type of it (i.e. tawîl). These teachings which are ascribed to the Quranic verses and possibly are their tawîl, have, at the first glance, no congruence with the ẓâhir (outward meaning) of the Quran. It is said that considering the narrations in which mention has been made of the Ahl al- Bayt's mastery of tawîl, and the traditions in which it has been claimed that the Quran has baṭn (an inner layer of meaning), it is understood that these teachings are the same baṭn and tawîl.
This article intends to analyze the relation between the ẓâhir of the Quran and baṭinî tawîls (interpretations of the inner layer of the meaning). The writer believes that by tawîl and baṭn, in this group of traditions, it is not meant that they are infra-linguistic, rather (proves that) a number of them are incongruent with the ẓâhir of the Quran, and a group of them are beyond the realm of the technical sense of tawîl.Keywords: traditions of presenting the hadiths to the Quran, traditions of baṭini ta', wil (interpretation of the inner layer of the meaning), evaluation of tradition, batini tawîl -
Pages 59-80In this research the traditions are classified in four groups: 1) verbal allegiance along with bodily action, 2) bodily action, 3) verbal allegiance, 4) permissibility of shaking non-mahram women (or men) by the hand under the condition of existence of a cover (e.g. gloves, etc. as an impediment to direct touch).
By studying the content of those traditions it is concluded that many of (seemingly) contradictory traditions are indeed complements to one another and can be brought together. Only those traditions are unacceptable that denote permissibility of shaking hands (with a non-mahram) without there be an impediment to direct touch. In addition, the effects of the verse (Q 60:12) on these traditions become clear, because on the one hand the atmosphere of paying allegiance to the Prophet (S) by the women is elucidated by different groups of traditions, and on the other hand the authenticity of the related traditions can be examined by studying the cause of revelation of this verse.Keywords: Ikhtilâf al Hadith, Prophet Muhammad (S), woman, shaking hands, the surah of Mumtaḥanah (Q 60) -
Pages 81-103which is a tradition ascribed to Imam Ali (A.S) mentioned in literatures having a mystical approach, has at times been explained in the mystical and philosophical heritage and about which many monographs have been written on occasion. This fact that emphasizes the necessity of evaluation of this tradition, is studied this article.
The investigations indicate that Ibn Ṭalḥh Shâfiî living in the seventh/eleventh century was the first person who considered in his book al-Durr al-munaẓẓam fî al-sirr al-aẓam this sentence as Imam Alis discourse. However, neither he nor later scholars who deemed the sentence attributed to the Imam have mentioned any evidence (or isnâd) for their
claim. On the other hand such individuals as Ayn al-Quât Hamadânî, Samânî, Ibn Arabî and Saîdud-din Furghanî have deemed it the words of Shiblî, the Sufi. At the same time Abu Sad Khargûshî in his Tahdhîb al- Asrâr, Abu l-Qâsim Qushayrî in his al-Risâlah al-Qushayriyyah, Ghazzâlî in his Iḥyâ al-Ulûm , and Aṭṭâr Nayshâbûrî in his Tadhkirat al-Awliyâ
believe that it is the discourse of an unknown contemporary of Shiblî.
In addition, non-existence of dots in the Arabic script in the early Islam,the history of adding dots in the Muṣḥafs, and adding dots as diacritic marks to them, as well as the Muṣḥafs free of dots attributed to the Infallibles (A.S)
in the first/seventh century, non-application of the (term) dot in its technical meaning in the traditions and finally, the fact that the narrative supporters (of this attribution) are weak and fail to denote the above claim,all of these make one question the attribution of this tradition to the Commander of the Faithful (A.S). All of these issues are examined in this article.Keywords: Imam Ali (A.S), Shiblî, mystical transmitted traditions, the dot under the letter ba -
Pages 104-134The hadith of the Infallibles has constantly been one of major sources in inferring the religious knowledge and teachings in various ranges. Attention to this category has preoccupied certain Twelver Shia scholars, namely the traditionists and text-inclined scholars who were committed not to transgress the specified limits of the traditions. Based on this, they just attempted in such different fields as theology, exegesis, jurisprudence, etc. to present their system of thought through transmitting and classifying the text of hadiths.
Presenting the thought within the narrative texts in an implicit way and failure in specifying it has caused difficulty in its recognition.
Muhammad b. Hasan Ṣaffâr, the compiler of the book Baṣâir al-Darajât,is one of text-inclined scholars who has attempted to expose his approach in the realm of doctrines, and Imamate in particular to the public view in his book.
An analysis on his way in dividing the book in chapters and putting similar narrative texts together shows that his basic concerns in the field of Imamate scholarship was the necessity of existence of the Imam, as well as his characteristics. Among these characteristics Ṣaffâr highly emphasizes on the knowledge of the Imam and the relevant issues like the sources,obtaining mediums, and scope of his knowledge along with the Imams power.Keywords: text, inclination, Basair al Darajat, Saffar, the Imam, knowledge, power -
Pages 135-157The expression yûnusî used for certain Shia hadith transmitters in Shaykh Ṭûsîs Kitâb al-Rijâl is a disputable and likely unclear expression in the Shia Rijal literature. Certain researchers defined the expression as tilmîdh Yûnus (Yûnuss pupil) and min aṣḥâb Yûnus (from among Yûnuss companions or adherents) denoting either censuring the transmitter
or praising him. Based on the investigations accomplished in the present research this understanding may not be right and the above definitions cannot elucidate and specify the exact meaning of the expression in question.
Scrutiny of the relationship between instances of transmitters - about whom such an expression had been applied - and Yûnus b. `Abd al-Raḥmân,and the role they played in propagating the beliefs of Yûnus shows that the expression yûnusî (used for a number of hadith transmitters) denotes in its correct and exact meaning that the transmitter was a distinguished personality from the aspect of adhering to a particular theological sect
attributed to Yûnus that at least in the eyes of certain hadith masters of Qum
signified the transmitters censure.Keywords: theological viewpoints of the Shia Imams companions, theological differences, al, jarḥ wa al tadil (invalidation, validation), Yunus b. Abd al Rahman, yunusi -
Pages 158-182Many of the surviving works belonging to the Nuṣayryya denomination in the middle AH centuries contain countless quotations of the lost legacy of the Ghulât (extremists) of Kufa on which one can rely as intermediate.resources in retrieving the content of that legacy and consequently, the immediate understanding of the Ghulâs teachings. Kitâb al-Aẓilla is an instance of this kind of the Ghulâts legacy paragraphs of which are accessible through the medium of four old texts of the Nuṣayriyya denomination. Determining the aproximate date of compilation of these intermediate works can be helpful in dating the Kitâb al-Aẓilla and even in recognizing its author. Textual existing evidences confirm that these resources had been compiled in the third/ninth and fourth/tenth centuries,and this way it can be said that Kitâb al-Aẓilla dates back to a time earlier than the second/eighth or third/ninth century. Mention has been made of the three compilers of Kitâb al-Aẓilla in the Imami bibliographical references: Ahmad b. Muhammad b. Isâ Asharî Qummî, Abd al-Raḥmân b. Kathîr Hâshimî and Abu Jafar Muhammad b. Sinân Zâhirî, namely the authors
whose age of life coincides with the estimated time span of compilation of the book under discussion.
Based on the isnâds (transmission chains) available in Nusayrî resources (as access channels) to Kitâb al-Aẓilla it is more probable that the book belongs to Muhammad b. Sinân.Keywords: Kitab al Azilla, Ghulat of Kufa, the Nusayriyya denomination, Silsilat al turath al alawi