The study of the content of the statement, «The rule of unbelievers continues to existence while the unjust rule has no chance of existing»

The critique of chain of transmitters of Hadith and its content is of great importance for distinction between the traditions of the Infallibles (AS) and the non-Hadith statements. The study of the content of the statement, "The rule of unbelievers continues to existence while the unjust rule has no chance of existing" indicates that this sentence not only has not a valid document, but some scholars have denied its attribution to the Infallibles (AS). Additionally, it does not have an acceptable content. Three possible concepts of this proposition: the necessity of the continuation of a just government and the fall of the ruthless government, the signification of continuity and collapse of governments for their justice and injustice and the implication of justice and oppression by governments for their legitimacy and lack of legitimacy, are incompatible with Quranic verses, narrations and historical evidence. Of course, if it means to emphasize the importance of one agent from among the set of factors involved in the continuation or collapse of the state, it is acceptable and consistent with the Quran, narrations, and historical evidences.