Criticism and Analysis of the Physical Appearance of Imam Ali (p.b.u.h), The Commender of the Faithful, in Sunni Sources

In the works authored by Sunni outstanding scholars on the character of Imam Ali in particular, or that of the Companions of the Holy Prophet in general, certain chapters are devoted to his outward features. It is noteworthy that some Shiite scholars have also taken the qualities stated in these sources as granted, quoting them in their own books. Revisiting this issue and criticizing as well as analyzing the qualities mentioned in Sunni sources, the co- authors of this article have concluded that some of these features reflect Imam Ali´s real appearance corresponding to the reports of other Sunni sources and those of Shiite ones. According to these sources, the two qualities of “ Anza” and “Batin” attributed to Imam Ali by the holy Prophet, can be accepted through the explanation given by the Holy Prophet himself. However, some other qualities of Imam Ali (p.b.u.h) although apparently mentioned in praise of him, the real aim behind them has been tarnishing his image.