The Position of Criticism in the History of Medicine Based on "A Critique of the Article, Abu al-Hasan Ahmad ibn Muhammad al-Tabari Toranji; the Famous Iranian Physician"

Historical criticism requires expertise and proficiency in general knowledge of history. Without historical knowledge, it is wrong to write a review. In writing the critique of the article "Abu al-Hasan Ahmad ibn Muhammad al-Tabari Toranji; the famous Iranian physician", year 2022, volume 24, number 1, none of the principles of historiography criticism have been observed. With a focus on historical geography, there is apparently a difference of opinion between the critics and the author of the article. Therefore, the aim of this article is critical discourse analysis of historiography and the birthplace of  Abu al-Hasan Ahmad ibn Muhammad al-Tabari Toranji.