A critique on the evidence of the theory of happiness on the day of Ashura

The authentic Shiite belief of mourning and crying for the martyrs originated from the Sunnah of the Prophet and the Ahl al-Bayt, however, the enemies of the Ahl al-Bayt & especially the Umayyads, fearing the spread of their crimes and deviations, fought with all their might against this awakening wave, and unfortunately, some sects such as Sufiya accompanied them and they have influenced a number of people among the society by casting doubt. In this article, after examining the claims made by this school of thought, it was found that none of them indicate the claims, as some of them are not innocent words and deeds or have weak documents. Now, on the premise, the existence of a Sahih al-Sanhad tradition that indicates happiness on the day of Ashura is in conflict with the hadiths that indicate the order to be sad, sorrowful and cry on the day of Ashura. that this news says: "what is against Sunnis should be the standard of action"; This combination between the narrations that you are both happy and sad is an axiomatic combination that has no evidence or evidence and the practice of Ahl al-Bayt is also contrary to it.