lecture-based learning
در نشریات گروه پزشکی-
Effective educational strategies are crucial for developing moral sensitivity in nursing students. Traditional lecture-based methods may lack engagement, prompting the exploration of game-based approaches. This study compares the impacts of game-based and lecture-based teaching on nursing students' moral sensitivity.In this quasi-experimental study, 46 fourth-semester nursing students from Rafsanjan University of Medical Sciences participated. The control group received traditional lectures, while the intervention group engaged in game-based learning focused on moral scenarios in eight 90-minute sessions.Of the initial 46 students, 42 completed the study. Both groups had similar demographics. Post-intervention, the game-based group showed a statistically significant increase in total moral sensitivity scores (P = 0.017). Additionally, they scored higher in “experience of ethical problems and conflicts” (P = 0.044) and in “sincerity and benevolence” (P = 0.007) compared to the lecture group. It was concluded that game-based teaching methods significantly enhance moral sensitivity among nursing students compared to traditional lectures, particularly in areas related to ethical conflicts and benevolence. Future research should focus on the long-term effects and integration of game-based learning in nursing education.
Keywords: Ethics Education, Moral Sensitivity, Game-Based Learning, Lecture-Based Learning, Nursing Student -
Background
Gestational diabetes mellitus (GDM) is the most common medical complication of pregnancy, resulting both maternal and fetal/neonatal negative consequences. Since health care staff in health care centers, including general practitioners and midwives encounter the condition at the first line, they should be well trained about it. This study aimed to investigate whether the problem-based learning (PBL) or the lecture-based learning (LBL) method is preferred regarding medical pedagogy.
MethodA descriptive test about GDM screening and diagnosis was given to the health care staff of 10 health care centers in Mashhad. 66 individuals with the lowest points were involved in the study in two groups of 33. The first group joined a lecture-based educational program about GDM, while the other group were trained using the PBL method. After a week, a test was given to them, and the results were compared between the two groups.
ResultsThe scores of the gestational diabetes diagnosis test in both groups increased significantly after the training (change from 3.50±1.40 to 6.20±1.51 in the PBL group, P<0.001; and 3.32±1.64 to 5.58±1.66, P<0.001). There was no significant difference in the results between the two groups (P=0.13).
ConclusionThe results of PBL educational programs about GDM are not superior to the results of the LBL method.
Keywords: Gestational Diabetes, Lecture-Based Learning, Problem-Based Learning, Diabetes Screening -
مقدمهدر آموزش پزشکی، مطالعاتی در زمینه مقایسه روش های آموزش بر پایه حل مساله و آموزش بر پایه سخنرانی انجام گرفته و لیکن با توجه به عادات یادگیری دانشجویان ایرانی و شرایط خاص آموزش، اثرات بکارگیری این دو روش در این محیط کمتر بررسی شده است. بنابراین، مطالعه ای به منظور مقایسه دو روش آموزش بر پایه حل مساله و سخنرانی بر میزان دانش دانشجویان در درس بیولوژی مولکولی و تعیین نگرش گروه حل مساله در مورد این شیوه آموزشی انجام گردید.روش هااین مطالعه نیمه تجربی بر روی دانشجویان پزشکی ورودی بهمن 1381 دانشگاه علوم پزشکی اصفهان (64 نفر) انجام شد.نیمی تصادفی از این دانشجویان برای یادگیری مهارت های پیشنیاز در یک کارگاه آموزشی سه روزه شرکت نمودند. گروه تجربی درس بیولوژی را به صورت آموزش بر پایه حل مساله، زیر نظر دانشجویان پزشکی سال بالاتر فرا گرفتند و گروه شاهد در کلاس درس معمول با روش سخنرانی همان مباحث را آموزش دیدند. در پایان دوره، آزمون دانش به صورت سوالات چهار گزینه ای و تشریحی پاسخ کوتاه از هر دو گروه گرفته شد. یافته ها با استفاده از آزمون آماری T-test در نرم افزار SPSS مورد پردازش قرار گرفت.نتایجمیانگین دانش گروه تجربی 7/1±3/14 و گروه شاهد 8/1±8/12 و میانگین نمره دانش گروه مداخله 1.5 نمره بیشتر از میانگین نمره گروه شاهد تفاوت آنها معنی دار بود. همچنین، نگرش دانشجویان گروه تجربی نسبت به شیوه آموزشی مثبت بود.
بحث:مطالعه حاضر حاکی از موفق بودن دوره آموزش بر پایه حل مساله در مقابل شیوه های رایج بود و پیشنهاد می شود با مطالعات بیشتر و عمیق تر، امکان بکارگیری آموزش بر پایه حل مساله بجای روش آموزشی مرسوم بررسی شود.
کلید واژگان: آموزش پزشکی، آموزش بر پایه حل مساله، دانشجویان پزشکی، آموزش بر پایه سخنرانیIntroductionIn the previous studies in the field of medical education, problem based learning and lecture based learning have been compared, but, due to the learning habits of Iranian students and special condition of education, the effects of these two methods have been less investigated in Iranian universities so far. This study attempts to compare the effects of these two methods on students’ knowledge in molecular biology course and also to assess students’ attitude towards this course in problem based learning group.MethodsThis quasi-experimental study was applied on first year medical students of Isfahan University of Medical Sciences (64 students). Half of the students, after taking part in a 3 day PBL workshop for learning the needed skills, started working in PBL groups under the supervision of the students of higher levels. The control group spent the course with the traditional lecture method. At the end of the course, students’ knowledge was assessed by multiple choice questions and short answer essay questions in both groups and also the attitude of experimental group was assessed by a questionnaire. The data was analyzed by SPSS software using t-test.ResultsThe mean score of knowledge was 14.3±1.7 and 12.8±1.8 in the experiment and control group, respectively. There was a significant difference between the knowledge score of the experiment and control groups. The attitude of the experimental group towards the applied educational method was positive.ConclusionThe present study revealed that Problem Based Learning method was successful compared with current learning methods. More studies are recommended to consider replacing the current educational methods with problem based learning method.Keywords: Medical education, Problem Based Learning, Medical students, Lecture Based Learning -
Background According to the available evidence, problem-based learning (PBL) is one of the most successful methods in achieving higher educational objectives. In this method, the discussion about the subjects that should be taught to the students is based on a real clinical case.Various advantages and disadvantages of this method have been addressed in difJerent studies, but the students' attitude toward this method is vita/for its success.Objective To evaluate the students• altitude toward problem- based learning and to compare it with lecture-based learning.Method In this experimental study, two topics of basic immunology were chosen after holding coordination meetings. The students were divided randomly into two groups.Group A received PBLfor the first and LBLfor the secondtopic, and group B had LBLfor thefu-st and PBLfor the second topic. After the last session, a questionnaire was given to the students.Results The students considered PBL as superior in view of the student's active role in education. According to the students' opinion, group working was more evident in PBL. Although they preferred LBL to be used in a complete immunology course, they suggested that PBL is good to be used in some of the sessions.They suggested that although the learner's role is more evident in PBL, the instructor's role is still significant. They believed that self-assessment is better and easier in PBL.Discussion According to the results it is clear that, at least in some aspects, the students' attitude toward PBL is positive.This shows that by considering these aspects in educational reform programs, and by further study on the items not definitely determined in this research, we could modify PBL so that it could be used in a broader level.
Keywords: Attitude, Problem-based learning, Lecture-based learning
- نتایج بر اساس تاریخ انتشار مرتب شدهاند.
- کلیدواژه مورد نظر شما تنها در فیلد کلیدواژگان مقالات جستجو شدهاست. به منظور حذف نتایج غیر مرتبط، جستجو تنها در مقالات مجلاتی انجام شده که با مجله ماخذ هم موضوع هستند.
- در صورتی که میخواهید جستجو را در همه موضوعات و با شرایط دیگر تکرار کنید به صفحه جستجوی پیشرفته مجلات مراجعه کنید.