Analysis and Criticism of the Validation of Tha'albi's and Baghoi's Exegesis from Ibn Taymiyyah's Point of View

Tafsir al-Maalem al-Tanzir fi al-Tafsir va Ta'awil written by Baghoi is a summary of Tafsir Al-Saqat va Al-Bayan an Tafsir al-Qur'an by Tha'labi. Ibn Taymiyyah, one of the Sunni scholars, praised Baghvi's exegesis and on the other hand criticized Thaalbi's exegesis and considered Thaalbi to be one of the people who was not able to distinguish authentic hadith from unauthentic ones, and who narrated weak and fake hadiths. The main question of the research is why, despite the fact that Baghoi summarized Taalbi's exegesis, Ibn Taymiyyah praised Baghoi's exegesis, but Taalbi's work is open to criticism. The results of the research show that Baghoi removed some of Thaalbi's narrations (mostly the accounts regarding the virtues of Ahl al-Bayt) and the most important reason for Ibn Taymiyyah's criticism is based on the virtues that Thaalbi has stated. Also, due to the fact that the Shi'ites have cited Taalbi's exegesis, Ibn Taymiyyah has been very harsh in his treatment of Taalbi. In this research, we will answer the main question of the research using a library method in collecting the materials, the documentary method in conveying the views, and the descriptive-analytical method in examining the