فهرست مطالب

فصلنامه مطالعات و تحقیقات اجتماعی در ایران
سال نهم شماره 4 (زمستان 1399)

  • تاریخ انتشار: 1399/10/06
  • تعداد عناوین: 10
|
  • سارا فریدزاده* صفحات 771-797

    هدف اصلی مقاله پیش رو بررسی نحوه برساخت مرز و مرزگذاری فرهنگی و اجتماعی در سفرنامه ظهیرالدوله (همراه مظفرالدین شاه به فرنگ) است. این سفرنامه که در بحبوحه انقلاب مشروطه نگاشته شده، از لحاظ جایگاه اجتماعی- سیاسی نگارنده حایز اهمیتی ویژه است. بحث توسعه یافتگی و مدرنیزاسیون جامعه ایرانی، لاجرم در ارتباط با کشورهای غربی پیوندی تنگاتنگ داشته است. به طور تاریخی و حتی در دوران معاصر، همیشه این سوال مطرح بوده است که چگونه می توانیم ضمن برقراری و حفظ رابطه با غرب، الگویی مطلوب برای توسعه جامعه ایرانی فراهم کنیم؟ این رابطه برای جامعه ایران با مسایل و پیچیدگی های فراوانی همراه بوده و از دوره قاجار تاکنون هیچ گاه از این پیچیدگی ها و تنش ها کاسته نشده است. با جستن ریشه های تاریخی و فرهنگی و پژوهش درباره اساس شکل گیری این رابطه در بستری تاریخی می توان به درک همه جانبه تری از هویت درحال شکل گیری جامعه ایران دست یافت. همچنین تلاش بر این است که با تحلیل محتوای قسمت های منتخب سفرنامه مذکور، نخستین لحظه هایی که در آن انواع مرزهای اجتماعی و فرهنگی به شکل دهی مفهومی «هویت ایرانی» دامن زده اند، ثبت شود. به علاوه نشان داده شده است که چگونه در این قبیل سفرنامه ها محور توجه از پیشرفت کشورهای مقصد به نقص های جامعه ایران معطوف شده است و بیشتر از آنکه دیگری ستایش شود، خود ملامت و سرزنش می شود.

    کلیدواژگان: امر بیگانه، برساخت، دوران قاجار، دیگری، سفرنامه ظهیرالدوله، شکل گیری گروه و هویت جمعی، مرزبندی اجتماعی و فرهنگی
  • سحر طالبی*، خدیجه سفیری، افسانه کمالی صفحات 799-826
    هدف پژوهش حاضر، ارایه مدلی تجربی از شرایط و فرایندهایی است که برسازنده امکان کنش جمعی در سطح محله ای هستند. با بهره گیری از روش مطالعه موردی، چهار کنش جمعی در محله های اکباتان، اوین، شهرک دانشگاه شریف و شهرک راه آهن، به عنوان موردهای پژوهش انتخاب شده است تا از خلال مطالعه میدانی آن ها به درکی از عناصر مشترکی دست یابیم که با وجود تفاوت در بستر و هدف کنش جمعی آن را ممکن ساخته اند. داده ها با روش های متعددی مانند مصاحبه نیمه ساخت یافته، بررسی اسناد، مشاهده میدانی و گروه کانونی گردآوری شدند. یافته های پژوهش در دو سطح شرایط و بستر کنش جمعی و راهبردهای شکل دهنده آن تنظیم شدند. در سطح بستر کنش جمعی، مفاهیم عاملیت آغازگر، سرمایه اجتماعی محلی و ساختار قدرت محلی به عنوان مقوله های اثرگذار بر شرایط امکان کنش جمعی از داده ها انتزاع شدند. در سطحراهبرد ها نیز مفاهیم چارچوب دهی مسئله کنش و بسیج منابع کنش، کنش های صورت گرفته برای شکل گیری و استمرار کنش جمعی را بازنمایی می کنند. مدل نشان می دهد چگونه هرکدام از مفاهیم موجود در منظومه مفهومی ارایه شده، بر امکان شکل گیری و استمرار کنش جمعی اثرگذار هستند و چگونه رابطه متقابل میان مفاهیم مدل و تاثیر آن ها بر یکدیگر و تعامل و مشروط کنندگی متقابل میان عاملیت کنشگران اجتماعی و ویژگی های ساختاری بستر کنش، برسازنده امکان کنش جمعی است.
    کلیدواژگان: بسیج منابع، چارچوب دهی، سرمایه اجتماعی، کنش جمعی، نفع عمومی
  • ملیحه عرشی، محمد سبزی خوشنامی*، الهام محمدی، مرضیه تکفلی، فرانک ایمانی صفحات 827-854
    پدیده کودکان خیابانی یکی از آسیب های اجتماعی جوامع مدرن و صنعتی است. در ایران، سازمان بهزیستی از سال 1384، متولی طرح سامان دهی کودکان خیابانی شده است. این مطالعه، میزان اثربخشی این طرح در نیل به اهدافش را بررسی کرده است. روش پژوهش حاضر پیمایشی از نوع توصیفی-تحلیلی است. جامعه آماری پژوهش نیز شامل کودکان خیابانی مراکز سامان دهی کودکان کار خیابانی بهزیستی استان های منتخب (سراسر کشور) و والدین یا سرپرستان این کودکان است. ابزار پژوهش مصاحبه و پرسشنامه محقق ساخته براساس اهداف طرح بوده است. یافته های پژوهش نشان می دهد تغییر معنادار و موثری در وضعیت اشتغال به تحصیل کودکان ایجاد نشده است. بعد از مداخله در طرح، وضعیت کار کودک به صورت معناداری کاهش یافته است؛ به طوری که حدود 23 درصد کودکان بعد از مداخله کار نمی کنند. با توجه به هدف بهبود سامان یابی کودکان خیابانی، حدود 15 درصد کودکان از سرپرستی والدین بی کفایت خود خارج شده اند. درباره وضعیت طرح در دستیابی به هدف بهبود ظرفیت های خانواده، درمجموع تنها 20 درصد از خانواده های این کودکان با توجه به معیارها توانمند شدند. با توجه به یافته های این پژوهش می توان عنوان کرد که طرح سامان دهی کودکان خیابانی با وجود اینکه در نیل به برخی اهداف موفق بوده است، توانمندسازی کودکان و خانواده ها در سطح قابل قبولی صورت نگرفته است و در دستیابی به مجموع اهداف خود نیاز به برنامه ریزی تخصصی تر وجود دارد؛ بنابراین نیاز است با توجه به ارزشیابی طرح، تغییراتی در اهداف، تعاریف، نحوه عملکرد و خدمات تخصصی ایجاد شود. پیشنهاد می شود شاخص های کمی و کیفی قابل سنجش برای اهداف طرح سامان دهی کودکان خیابانی تعریف و رویکردهای مداخله مددکاری اجتماعی براساس دیدگاه های جدید تنظیم شود.
    کلیدواژگان: ارزشیابی، طرح سامان دهی، سازمان بهزیستی، کودک خیابانی، کودک کار
  • حمیدرضا جلائی پور، ابوالفضل حاجی زادگان* صفحات 855-877

    در این پژوهش، اجزای تشکیل دهنده «توییتر ایرانی» و الگوهای تاثیرپذیری کاربران ایرانی توییتر از نگرش های سیاسی اینفلوینسرهای توییتر ایرانی را شناسایی و ارزیابی کرده ایم. بدین منظور اینفلوینسرها و دنبال کننده ها (فالویرها) براساس گرایش های سیاسی شان دسته بندی شده اند و الگوهای تاثیرپذیری دنبال کننده ها از اینفلوینسرها به تفکیک گرایش های مختلف، شناسایی و ارزیابی شده است. در دسته بندی اینفلوینسرها و دنبال کننده ها از تکنیک های داده کاوی و در تحلیل داده های شبکه ای، از تحلیل های نرم افزار گفی (Gephi) استفاده کرده ایم. نتایج این پژوهش نشان می دهد، با وجود آنکه هیچ کدام از گرایش های سیاسی در توییتر ایرانی، از لحاظ مقبولیت در میان کاربران و اینفلوینسرها، برتری محسوسی به گرایش های رقیب ندارند، بخش قابل توجهی از کاربرانی که طرفدار هریک از گرایش های سیاسی موجودند، معمولا تمایل کمی دارند که در معرض پیام های سیاسی متفاوت قرار بگیرند و بیشتر سعی می کنند مطالبی منطبق یا نزدیک به نگرش های سیاسی خودشان را بخوانند.

    کلیدواژگان: اینفلوئنسر، توییتر، شبکه های اجتماعی آنلاین، نگرش سیاسی
  • بهنام بشیری خطیبی، علی باصری*، فیروز راد، نوروز هاشم زهی صفحات 879-906

    امروزه یکی از مسایل مهم و گاهی نگران کننده برای دولت مردان و خانواده های ایرانی، تجردگزینی جوانان است. این موضوع که عمدتا خواستگاه غربی دارد و با پیامدهای مختلف فردی و اجتماعی همراه است، نیازمند تحقیقات و مطالعات متعددی است که در این مقاله با رویکرد جامعه شناسانه به آن پرداخته شده است. روش پژوهش نظریه زمینه ای (گرندد تیوری) بوده و در میان دانشجویان تحصیلات تکمیلی دانشگاه آزاد اسلامی واحد علوم و تحقیقات بررسی و انجام شده است. روش جمع آوری داده ها نیز مصاحبه های نیمه ساختاریافته و عمیق بوده است. برای تحلیل از کدگذاری سه مرحله ای باز، محوری و گزینشی استفاده شده است. تجردگزینی و شرایط علی، زمینه ای و مداخله گرای آن، الگوی پارادایمی این تحقیق بوده است. درنهایت مشخص شد براساس الگوی کشف شده، تجردگزینی بستر مسایلی از قبیل کاهش رشد شخصی ادراک شده، بی اعتنایی به ازدواج، دوسوگرایی در ازدواج (مانند ترس و نگرانی از آینده)، تاخیر در سن ازدواج، وسواس در انتخاب، احساس ناتوانی احساسی و عاطفی و... می شود.

    کلیدواژگان: بی اعتنایی به ازدواج، تجردگزینی، دوسویه گرایی در ازدواج، رشد شخصی ادراک شده، گرندد تئوری
  • منوچهر رشادی* صفحات 907-930

    استان همدان ترکیبی از اقوام مختلف فارس، لر، ترک و کرد است که امروز بیش از هر زمان دیگری در یکدیگر ادغام شده اند و به صورت روزمره در تعامل و ارتباط با یکدیگرند. در بستر چنین تنوعی، موضوع اعتماد و مشارکت اجتماعی از اهمیت قابل توجهی برخوردار است. این پژوهش به روش کمی و با هدف بررسی ارتباط میان اعتماد اجتماعی و مشارکت اجتماعی در استان همدان انجام شده است. جامعه آماری آن را افراد 15 سال ساکن در 9 شهرستان استان تشکیل می دهد. این جمعیت شامل 612.449 نفر است که نمونه ای 800 نفری از آن ها مطالعه شد. یافته ها نشان می دهد اعتماد اجتماعی دارای میانگین 41/42 درصد و درنتیجه اندک است. درمقابل، میزان مشارکت اجتماعی با 61/89 زیاد است. براساس نتایج آزمون فرضیه ها، متغیرهای جنسیت، درآمد و تحصیلات ارتباط معناداری با اعتماد اجتماعی و مشارکت اجتماعی ندارند، اما رابطه سن با مشارکت معنادار و منفی است. در پژوهش حاضر، رابطه معنادار اعتماد و ابعاد آن (اعتماد نهادی، عمومی و بین فردی) با مشارکت اجتماعی اثبات شده است. به طورکلی و براساس یافته ها می توان گفت مشارکت اجتماعی بدون ارتقای سطح اعتماد اجتماعی در شهرهای استان همدان امری دشوار است؛ بنابراین ارتقای سطح اعتماد اجتماعی، به ویژه اعتماد نهادی از ضرورت های این امر است. عملکرد درست نهادها، به ویژه آن هایی که به طور مستقیم با مردم سروکار دارند، بسیار تعیین کننده است.

    کلیدواژگان: اعتماد اجتماعی، اعتماد بین فردی، اعتماد عمومی، اعتماد نهادی، مشارکت اجتماعی، همدان
  • زهره نصرت خوارزمی، فاطمه قاسمپور*، حنانه نصرت خوارزمی صفحات 931-966
    وقوع جمهوری اسلامی در ایران، فرصت ویژه ای برای کنشگری فرهنگی مبتنی بر آموزه های اسلام و نگاه ضدامپریالیستی به زنان بخشید. این امر عامل توانمندسازی جریان های مدنی زنان نیز بوده است. یکی از این جریان ها که در ادبیات بین الملل با عنوان فمینیسم اسلامی شناخته می شود، مدعی بازتفسیر ادبیات دینی مبتنی بر مفهوم مدرن برابری جنسیتی است. تدوین قوانین و تکوین هنجارهای اجتماعی، از جمله روابط زن و مرد در عرصه خانواده و اجتماع مبتنی بر قواعد اسلامی پس از انقلاب اسلامی، به زعم فمینیست های اسلامی جایگاه فرودستی برای زنان ایجاد کرده است و آن ها از همان مجاری دینی خواستار بازتعریف برخی قوانین و هنجارهای فرهنگی هستند. مقاله حاضر با بررسی منابع متعدد دانشگاهی و مطبوعاتی که گفتمان فمینیسم اسلامی را برساخته است، دال های مرکزی این گفتمان را در مواجهه با جمهوری اسلامی در ایران بیان کرده است. در اینجا، فمینیسم اسلامی بر مبنای نظریه مارگات بدران تعریف شده است و با استفاده از رویکرد لاکلا و موف در تحلیل گفتمان انتقادی دال های مرکزی بازشناسی شده است. نتایج پژوهش نشان می دهد، نقد رویکرد جمهوری اسلامی به تقلیل هویت زنانه به خانواده و اجتماع، تاکید بر برابری ارزشی زن و مرد برای دستیابی به تشابه حقوقی، توقف قانون گذاری نابرابر میان زنان و مردان مبتنی بر تفاسیر دینی و توسعه مشارکت زنان در جامعه مدنی از جمله موارد انتقاد فمینیسم اسلامی به جمهوری اسلامی است.
    کلیدواژگان: ایران، برابری جنسیتی، زنان، فمینیسم اسلامی
  • غلامرضا جمشیدیها، مریم شعبان* صفحات 967-994
    پژوهش حاضر براساس گفتمان مقاومتی شرق شناسی وارونه به دنبال ارایه شناختی از شرایط بومی جامعه ایران درباره چگونگی حقوق کودک است. بر مبنای مطالعه ای اکتشافی، شش حوزه داخلی و خارجی که مبنای تعریف حقوق کودک در ایران هستند، مبنی بر قوانین و مقررات ایران، سیاست گذاری های داخلی در سه عرصه حاکمیتی، دولتی و دیوان سالاری، جامعه مدنی ایران، سیاست گذاری های جامعه جهانی (بین الملل)، آیین دین اسلام و سیاست گذاری های جهان اسلام را شناسایی و سپس با روش تحلیل محتوای کیفی، تحلیل شده است. جامعه ایران با توجه به شرایط سنتی و اسلامی خود، کودک را در خانواده و تحت ولایت والدین یا سرپرستان درنظر می گیرد و با اولویت منافع جمعی در خانواده و جامعه به حمایت از کودک می پردازد. پیرو این اصل، کودک در خانواده حق حیات دارد، حتی اگر هنوز نطفه ای بیش نباشد. رعایت این حق نیز امری فرانسلی و فراتاریخی است که نسل های پیشین را دربر می گیرد. کودک در جمعی گسترده تر یا ساختاریافته تر مانند جامعه، حق استقلال، نداشتن استعمار و استحمار و همچنین نبود تحریم را دارد. کودکان جوامع اسلامی از جمله ایران به حقوقی نیاز دارند که در جوامع مرکز در پیمان نامه و کنوانسیون حقوق کودک به عنوان منابع جهانی مسلط مدنظر قرار نگرفته اند؛ گویی حقوق کودک در منابع جهانی، خوانشی جدا و فرسنگ ها دور از زمینه های اجتماعی و فرهنگی جوامع پیرامون (شامل اسلام و ایران) است. این موضوع، نیازمند توجه و اقدام جوامع پیرامونی برای ارایه «ساختار بومی حقوق کودک» است.
    کلیدواژگان: بومی گرایی، جوامع مرکز-پیرامون، حقوق کودک، حقوق کودک ایرانی-اسلامی، شرق شناسی وارونه
  • پژمان برخورداری*، سید حسین سراج زاده، عبدالمحمد کاظمی پور صفحات 995-1026
    این مقاله در پی مطالعه نحوه بازنمایی ابعاد مختلف دینداری طبقات اجتماعی در سینمای پس از انقلاب ایران است. ابعاد دینداری مورد نظر در پژوهش فعلی از مدل دینداری گلاک و استارک استخراج شده اند و همچنین دلالت مورد نظر از طبقه مبتنی بر نظریه تمایز بوردیو است. درنهایت دو سطح نظری مذکور در بستر رویکرد برساخت گرایی هال در باب بازنمایی، تحلیل شده اند. از میان ده ها فیلم سینمایی پس از انقلاب ایران، برای هر دهه دو فیلم که از لحاظ نظری قرابت بیشتری با معیارهای پژوهش داشتند، انتخاب و به روش نشانه شناسی انتقادی جان فیسک بررسی شدند. فیلم های انتخاب شده عبارت اند از: توبه نصوح (1361) و دو چشم بی سو (1363) در دهه شصت، از کرخه تا راین (1371) و بوی کافور، عطر یاس (1379) در دهه هفتاد، خانه ای روی آب (1380) و کتاب قانون (1387) در دهه هشتاد و رسوایی 1 (1391) و طبقه حساس (1392) در دهه نود. این فیلم ها در سه سطح واقعیت، بازنمایی و ایدیولوژی بررسی شدند. درنهایت نحوه ترکیب و به انسجام رسیدن دو سطح اول در سطح آخر یعنی ایدیولوژی نشان داده شدند. با استفاده از مطالعه نشانه شناختی فیلم ها، رمزگان های مربوط به ابعاد دینداری هر طبقه در هریک از دهه های بعد از انقلاب نشان داده شد. همچنین نشانه شناسی انتقادی فیلم ها حاکی از آن بود که بازنمایی ابعاد پنج گانه دینداری هریک از طبقات اجتماعی، متاثر از گفتمان های حاکم بر هر دهه، تغییرات مشخص و قابل توجهی داشته است. از جمله این تغییرات می توان به کاهش چشمگیر ابعاد دینداری طبقه فرودست، از جمله بعد عاطفی در مقایسه با دهه شصت، ثبات نسبی ابعاد دینداری طبقه متوسط از دهه هفتاد به بعد و همچنین پررنگ ترشدن بعد مناسکی دینداری طبقه مرفه در دهه اخیر اشاره کرد که چنین تغییرات و نوساناتی در نظام بازنمایی سینما متاثر از تغییرات گفتمان های حاکم بر هر دهه بوده است.
    کلیدواژگان: بازنمایی، دینداری، سینمای ایران، طبقات اجتماعی، نشانه شناسی انتقادی
  • یونس اکبری*، حسین میرزایی، ابوعلی ودادهیر صفحات 1027-1052
    با بیان واژه منفعت، اولین چیزی که بی درنگ به ذهن متبادر می شود، منفعت اقتصادی است؛ درحالی که میدان های مختلف زندگی منافع خاص خود را دارند که لزوما منفعت اقتصادی نیستند. پژوهش حاضر با استفاده از روش اسنادی به بررسی تنوع سطوح و معانی غیراقتصادی مفهوم منفعت از دیدگاه جامعه شناسان پرداخته است و قصد دارد با تاکید بر فهم بوردیویی از منفعت ابزاری مفهومی برای تبیین پدیده های اجتماعی در اختیار پژوهشگران قرار دهد. نتایج این پژوهش حاکی از این است که دو توکویل، وبر، راتزنهوفر، اسمال، السورث راس، زیمل و کلمن منفعت را در قالب خرد و فردی آن به کار گرفته اند. با این حال وجه تمایزی نیز میان متفکران مذکور درباره مفهوم منفعت وجود دارد و آن این است که توکویل، وبر، کلمن و زیمل مفهوم منفعت را عنصری اجتماعی درنظر گرفته اند و در تحلیل روابط میان افراد جامعه از آن استفاده کرده اند، اما راتزنهوفر، اسمال و راس درکی پیشااجتماعی از مفهوم منفعت دارند و آن را عنصری می دانند که سبب تشکیل جامعه می شود، نه عاملی که بتوان روابط میان افراد جامعه را به وسیله آن تحلیل کرد. نتایج این تحقیق حاکی از این است که متفکرانی مانند مارکس، بنتلی و بوردیو منفعت را در قالب جمعی و گروهی آن استفاده کرده اند. با وجود این، با نگاهی عمیق تر به آثار و کاربرد تجربی نظریه های متفکران فوق درباره مفهوم منفعت شاید بتوان بیان کرد که نگاه جامعه شناسانه مارکس به مفهوم منفعت در قالب منافع طبقاتی هرچند دارای بار جامعه شناسانه است و منفعت را مختص به فرد نمی داند، باز معنای اقتصادی از منفعت را برای گروهی از افراد هم رده درنظر دارد و به نوعی راه را برای تفکر و تامل درباره سایر اشکال متنوع و غیراقتصادی منفعت می بندد. دیدگاه بنتلی نیز با یکی کردن منفعت و گروه راه به این همانی تبیین ها می برد و به همین دلیل امکان کاربست تجربی و آزمون پذیری آن محدود می شود. با وجود این به نظر می رسد رویکرد نظری و روشی بوردیو به مفهوم منفعت دریچه امکان ها را به سوی نگاه غیراقتصادی به مفهوم منفعت در قالب جامعه شناسی و با معنایی غیراقتصادی باز می کند.
    کلیدواژگان: اقتصاد، بوردیو، جامعه شناسی، منفعت، میدان
|
  • Sara Faridzadeh * Pages 771-797
    Introduction

    Starting with the 19th century‘s European expansion and colonization, the contact between Europe and the non-European world has been disproportional. As emerging from Bitterli’s typology (1976) of a cultural encounter, this contact can be captured by two inseparable dimensions: the socio-political and the cultural. In the past forty years, the intercultural aspect of colonialism has gained currency in scholarship. Bitterli claims that history of colonialism must reorient itself completely. By this, he means that it cannot be explained solely by the changes in power and interest and the resulting political, administrative, and economic change. Similarly, Mary Louis Pratt (1992) argues that the analysis of the cultural contacts between Europe and the other parts of the world, which has influenced the colonial power relations, has been omitted from the analysis of power, and particularly so in the case of analyses starting from the non-European side.

    Method

    The present study is to explore the specificity of cultural boundary-drawing by Iranians traveling to Europe in the turn of the 20th century. The process of the cultural boundary-making and the boundary itself shall be observed and be described in its historical context. Travel writing, as a literary genre, and its practice by 19th and beginnings of the 20th century by Persians traveling to Europe can contribute to the understanding of how social actors construct groups as similar and different and how it shapes their understanding toward such groups.

    Results and discussion

    In Iran’s Qajar period, travel activities increased greatly, cumulating into a kind of golden era of Persian travel literature. In the numerous Persian reports of Europe, produced in this era, we find examples illuminating the tension between the motivation of assimilation on one side and the resistance towards import of stranger’s perceptions on the other side. Since fear and fascination have always been the ambivalent tendency of Iranians towards foreign cultures. Especially the travel report of Ẓahīr-ad-dawleh (1900), who traveled as a companion of Mụẓaffar-ad-dīn-šāh to Europe at the turn of the 20th century, is going to reveal much of the turbulences in Iranian society before the Constitutional Revolution of 1906. Despite Ẓahīr-ad-dawleh’s high political status at the court of Mụẓaffar-ad-dīn-šāh, his narrative appears critical and far from self-censorship. In similar conditions, other persons in the court who had the equal position did not dare to speak, not only because of losing their high rank but also because of losing their lives. What is interesting about Ẓahīr-ad-dawleh’s report is the comparative perspective that he maintains in his observations of the modern European conditions on one hand and the societal situation in Iran on the other hand. At the same time, however, he remains sober about the prospects of a complete acculturation with the European culture.

    Conclusion

    it can be argued that the travel writings have a lot to say but not discussed before. Despite this report’s unique thematic and formal properties, this travel writing has been rarely studied before. Particularly for a Persian travelogue like that of Ẓahīr ad-Dawleh, which was configured in regard to a European Other and during the novel experience of alterity, it would be very helpful to examine empirical qualitative data analysis and way it had come to the process of boundary-drawing. This act is one of the first steps towards constructing something that we name it in the future “the Iranian identity” and the (re)construction of a common history.

    Keywords: Social, cultural boundaries, boundary-making, Alterity, Diversity, the travelogue of Ẓahīr ad-Dawleh, exclusion, inclusion, Qajar era
  • Sahar Talebi *, Khadijeh Safiri, Afsaneh Kamali Pages 799-826
    Introduction
    In spite of diversity in definition, all forms of collective action have a common property: a group of people cooperating for a public good (Tomas, Louis, 2013). Because of the non-exclusive nature of public goods, the rational action is to free ride and don't contribute to the collective action. This is where the collective action problem arises. The collective action problems can vary according to the contextual state of where and when they are being studied. In this study, we tried to gain a better understanding of the mechanisms and conditions which lead to making collective action happen in Iran. There are some controversial judgements about collective action in Iran. This study aims to make a clearer idea about the issue, by conducting a field study research and analyze the neighborhood collective action as the analytical unit.  
    Method
    We used a multiple case studies method in our field survey of collective action. We used purposive sampling and theoretical sampling for finding our cases: “Ekbatan”, “Evin”, “Sharif residential complex” and “Rahahan residential complex”. 
    Results and discussion
    We suggest an empirical model of structures in two levels: The contextual conditions ("Social capital", "The neighborhood power structure" and "Initializer agent"), and the strategical conditions ("framing" and "mobilization"). This model represents different factors and concepts and the interactions among them, which make neighborhood collective action possible. The factors are derived from the field data of this study. 
    Conclusion
    The interaction among the factors of our model leads to a situation where collective action can happen. The concepts forming the contextual conditions of collective action are "Social capital", "The neighborhood power structure" and "Initializer agent" . It is the interaction among these concepts that trigger the public good as the goal of collective action. At the Strategy level, "framing" and "mobilization" are at work that have a bilateral effect on each other. Framing brings legitimacy for the mobilizations' mechanisms, and in return, the mobilization provides the resources needed for resonating the framing of collective action. The chance of having a successful collective action is also affected by the way structural concepts of the contextual conditions interact with the strategies that agents employ. Social capital makes the mobilization more accessible and create trust. The ability to effectively interact with the neighborhood power institutions, can bring legitimacy, make the mobilization process easier, and reduce the overall cost of collective action. The initializer agent forms the primary framing of the collective action and mobilize the primary forces and resources needed. The interaction among these factors with the mutual effects and the possibilities and restraints that they have on each other, make the collective action possible. Understanding these factors and their restraining and contributary effects on collective action is the first step for agents who want to make any changes via the collective action. This usage will only arise from the interaction of social agents' will and the structural constraints.
    Keywords: Collective action, public good, Social capital, Resource Mobilization, Framing
  • Maliheh Arshi, Mohammad Sabzi Khoshnami *, Elham Mohammadi, Marzieh Takaffoli, Farank Imani Pages 827-854
    Introduction
    State Welfare Organization has been appointed as responsible for managing street children since 2005 and delivering services to these children and their families through national Street Children Managing Plan. The Plan has four service delivery levels and the aim of this study is to evaluate the effectiveness of short term residential centers (second level centers) in achieving its goals. These centers have the facilities to reside street children up to 21 days and to deliver medical, nutrition, financial, social work, psychological, legal and job training services to street children and their families.
    Method
    This research is a descriptive-analytical survey. The statistical population of the study is all street children registered in short term residential centers and their parents/caretakers in four provinces selected by State Welfare Organization (Tehran, Kordestan, Semnan, and Sistan & Baluchestan). Data were collected by two researcher-made questionnaires for children and families. The total sample size was 279 but finally 124 cases of the children and 98 cases of caregivers filled questionnaires and the data were analyzed by SPSS software. According to the main objectives of evaluation, the self-report questionnaire of children consisted of six parts: education, child safety and abuse; working situation; caregiving and guardianship; quality of life; and professional empowerment. The self-report questionnaire of families also consisted of job services, financial empowerment and social rehabilitation. Face validity of both the questionnaires were confirmed by 10 experts in social science and social work fields.
    Results and discussion
    According to the findings, 96.42% of participated children were boys and 83.87 of them were Iranian. There wasn’t any meaningful difference in the status of children education after the program implementation. The status of children working hours was changed meaningfully as 23% of them didn’t work anymore. Given the status of caregiving and guardianship, about 15% of the children were not under the guardianship of their incompetent parents anymore and instead grandparents and relatives have more share of the caregiving. There was a meaningful difference in the status of basic needs of children (physical, health, shelter, love and nurturing) but the difference wasn’t meaningful in need of leisure. According to the goal of improving the family capacities, only 20% of the families were empowered due to the scales.
    Conclusion
    Overall, the Plan had a significant effect on working status and hours, guardianship, meeting basic needs and improving the quality of life of working children, but did not have a significant outcome on their education and secondary needs. Also children and their families believed that the services aiming empowerment weren’t enough and effective and only the financial supports could increase the working status and hours of the children and improve their education in some cases. Regarding the objective of improving education status of street children, it could be discussed that empowerment services and social rehabilitation of the families weren’t comprehensive and evidence-based and were limited to financial support. Also statelessness and having no identity cards weren’t addressed in the plan as the main obstacle of formal education. Improving the family capacities was among the main objectives of the plan, but the result of gaining this goal was not promising. According to the findings of this study, it can be stated that the national Street Children Managing Plan was not successful in achieving its goals, and the empowerment of children and families did not reached to an anticipated level. So, it is necessary for State Welfare Organization to expand evaluating programs to other aspect of the plan and also other collaborating organizations and NGOs should be involved to realize the comprehensive and universal picture of implementing national Street Children Managing Plan.
    Keywords: Street Children, Child Labor, State Welfare Organization, Iran, Evaluation
  • Hamidreza Jalaeipour, Abolfazl Hajizadegan * Pages 855-877
    Introduction

    In this research, through identifying the components of what is called “Iranian Twitter”, we tried to identify and evaluate the patterns Iranian Twitter users are affected by the political attitudes of the Iranian Twitter Influencers.

    Method

    In this study we decided to analyze the data on the communication networks between users and Influencers. The steps we took to answer the three questions of research were as follows: We identified the Iranian Twitter Influencers using snowball sampling. Then, by reviewing the pages of the influencers one by one, we recorded their characteristics in our list. Then, we collected the information about the communication network between the influencers, and used that as input for Gephi software. Finally, we calculated each group of users attributed to each political attitude, how much expose themselves to influencers with different political attitudes, on average.

    Results and discussion

    two-fifths of Principality users are considered to be fanatic users. A fanatic user is a person who follows more than 70% of the influencers  and has the same political attitude. In fact, the fanatic user is one who is often exposed to one type of political attitude and is less inclined to be exposed to different opinions. Only 1% of transformationalist users were fanatic users. On average, 56% of the influencers followed by a reformist user with reformist attitudes. Also, transformationalist users are more likely to follow non-political influencers (44%) than to follow transformationalist influencers (33%). The complete isolation of separatists is evident in this table, as they have no share in the influencers followed by reformist, transformationalist, and principalist users, and only 1% of the them are followed by subversives supported the separation of Iran. Further, 64% of  influencers are also followed by principalist users tended to be principalist.

    Conclusion

    The results showed that although none of the political attitudes in Iranian Twitter have significant superiority to others, a significant proportion of users who favored a political attitude, displayed little tendency to be exposed to different political messages. Another important point is that online social networks should not necessarily be seen as a tool for organizing movements or revolutions. Influencers of online social networks affect attitudes of ordinary users by the contents that they publish constantly in long term. The continuous and daily influence of these new media in shaping the lifestyle, habits and attitudes of users is also important. If we do not understand the important role the online social networks could play in daily lives of users, we could not understand how they influence in political contexts.

    Keywords: online social networks, Twitter, Influencer, Political Attitudes
  • Behnam Bashiri Khatibi, Ali Baseri *, Firouz Rad, Norouz Hashem Zehi Pages 879-906
    Introduction

    Most of youth population and particularly young students prefer to have celibacy life style and remain single. Nowadays it has become widespread life style of most youths in Iran especially in educated and rich families. If, until now the financial and economic problems, education and employment has been considered the main obstacle of youth’s marriage or cause of their reluctance to marriage, but it seems that there are other problems in this choise that they prefer single life relative to married life. The purpose of the present research ply commentary approach and Emic view and among involved people to analyze the preferences of the young Iranian individuals to have celibacy life style via sociological analysis. 

    Method

    The methodology of this study is qualitative analysis conducted by use of grounded theory (Grounded Theory). The desired sample was selected among single students of Science & Research Branch on Islamic Azad University of Tehran (boys >28 years-old & girls>25 years-old) and through purposeful sampling. To collect data, deep and Semi-Structured interviews were utilized. For analysis of data, the constant and 3 phases of comparative analysis methods, Straus & Corbin has been used by the authors.

    Results and discussion

    The findings of research showed that major causes of the preferences are including social and cultural problems, past experiences and imperfect patterns as causal conditions and environmental, family pressures and economical & financial problems as grounding conditions as well as ignorance of opposite part lack of associates support and lack of necessary motives to marriage as intervention conditions in celibacy selection of youths. Finally, based on obtained data from statistical sample and extracted codes, the consequences of such life style has been explained as elimination and/or reduced perceived personal growth, indifference to marriage, double side approach on marriage, delay in marriage age, higher age of marriage and so on.

    Conclusion

    Since Iranian society in recent decades has experienced great changes in the cultural and social arena, which in turn has had a great impact on changing the views and thinking of individuals. This change of perspective begins with the individual and continues with the modeling of the core family lifestyle. What is perceived in the interviews with some participants is that urban youth have more choice of marriage time and living in the city due to low social connections between families and relatives and low involvement of large families (such as grandparents, uncles, cousins). In the decisions of the usually young nuclear family, less pressure is placed on marriage, or even the expansion of friendships with the opposite sex and job requirements in cities, has made the mandatory view of marriage in cities less colorful and less important than rural areas. Solving the problems of marriage requires a widespread cultural and public education. Encouraging young people and families to facilitate marriage and marital living, spreading the right culture of marriage and creating a space for marriage discourse in society can be effective in this regard. Finally, it should be said that in our country due to the lack of a organization in charge of family affairs and marriage and as a result of family confusion and bureaucracy in some related organizations and institutions, as well as to fulfill the tenth principle of the Constitution Islamic Republic of Iran to facilitate the formation of the family and also to create conditions for targeting the lifestyle of young people based on their circumstances intensified the situation among the youth.  Therefore, it seems necessary to have a strong and powerful institution or organization in the field of family to manage of young people.

    Keywords: Celibacy life Style, Family Pressures, Mutual Attitudes, Disagreement, Conflict of Values, Social Indifference, Perfectionism, and Grounded Theory
  • Manojehr Reshadi * Pages 907-930
    Introduction

    Hamedan is one of the provinces of Iran with a full-fledged mirror of the diversity of Iranian society. On the other hand, like other provinces, it has undergone changes due to the experience of development programs. Hamedan is a combination of different ethnic groups of Persians, Lors, Turks and Kurds that today more than ever before are integrated into each other and are in daily interaction and communication with each other. In the context of such diversity, the issue of trust and social participation is of considerable importance.

    Method

    This study aimed to investigate the relationship between social trust and social participation in Hamadan province. This study is conducted by a quantitative method. The statistical population consists of all people aged over 15 years living in 9 cities of the province, which is 612449 people. A samples of 800 individuals have been selected for the analysis. The required data were collected through a researcher-made questionnaire.

    Results and discussion

    The results have indicated that, in general, the level of social trust is low with an average of 42.41% in the study population. Meanwhile, institutional trust is lower than other dimensions of trust with an average of 38.56. The level of social participation is also high with 89.61. Informal participation is lower than formal participation. The results of the hypothesis test have indicated that the variables of gender, income and education have no significant relationship with social trust and social participation. But the relationship between age and participation is significant and negative; that is, as people get older, participation decreases. Both the variables of trust and its dimensions (institutional, public and interpersonal trust) have a significant relationship with social participation. Regression results have also indicated that, in general, the research variables could predict 0.63% of changes in social participation.

    Conclusion

    In general, based on the findings, it can be said that social participation is a difficult task without improving the level of social trust in the cities of Hamadan province. Therefore, raising the level of social trust, especially institutional trust, is a necessity. The proper functioning of institutions, especially those that deal directly with the people, is crucial. Institutions such as banks, municipalities, law enforcement, the judiciary, etc. are decisive in this regard.

    Keywords: social trust, institutional trust, Public trust, interpersonal trust, social participation, Hamadan
  • Zohreh Nosrat Kharazmi, Fatemeh Ghasempour *, Hannaneh Nosrat Kharazmi Pages 931-966
    Introduction
    The historic revival of the political Islam late 1970s and the establishment of the Islamic Republic in Iran as an unprecedented form of government has attracted many international scholars for four decades. From the very beginning of this socio-political transition in Iran, the status of women and their rights and empowerment have been of high priority under an Islamic government. The Islamic Republic has become an enabling force to bring an exceptional opportunity for Iranian women to acknowledge their position in individual and social capacities. Simultaneously, the definition of womanhood and women’s social mission and role taking has changed a lot based on new Islamic cultural values and laws in the Islamic Republic. In parallel, some new and different interpretations came to surface in particular during Mohammad Khatami’s presidency and under the title of dynamic jurisprudence was giving way to Islamic feminism. Islamic feminists claim to re-interpret Quran and the Prophet’s Sunnah in terms of modern gender equality and women’s socio-political participation. However, “Islamic” and “feminism” sounds paradoxical to many critics, “Islamic feminism” is a named phenomenon and a theorized body of knowledge that got its climax in 1990s as it sounds to remain significant in the 21st century.
    Method
    The present study is an attempt to seize the focal discursive nodes of Islamic feminism regarding both academic and journalistic literature with acknowledging the fact that many of the current Islamic feminists are not even located in Iran as they produce and publish such knowledge in European and American universities. The present study, thus, addresses various academic and journalistic publications to unveil the focal nodes that constructs the discourse of Islamic feminism in Iran. It has covered a vast literature including 40 articles, book chapters and books in the Islamic feminism genre to unveil its discursive construction in Iran. It employs Laclau and Mouffe’s approach to critical discourse analysis: it finds the most frequent concepts that imply the re-reading of Islam in terms of gender equality and women’s rights and empowerment.
    Results and discussion
    The study indicates that Islamic feminism that has developed in response to the political Islam discursively focuses on four major themes, including a) criticizing the Islamic Republic for reductionism in women’s identity into the domestic and communal roles, b) emphasis on human dignity to achieve the legal equality, c) demand on halting gender-based discriminatory legislature, and finally, d) fostering women’s participation in civil society.
    Conclusion
    To provide a compatible version of Islam with women’s modern needs and wishes is a dilemma with which many Muslim scholars and activists are faced. Islamic feminists in Iran challenge the pervasive narrative of womanhood post Revolution since they believe it has undermined women’s position as individuals and reinforced men’s power and control over women. Studies such as the present one paves the way for a vigorous dialogue between Islam and modernity in the field of gender. It draws the complex status of modern Muslim women in border thinking between Islam and modernity.
    Keywords: Islamic feminism, Political Islam, Iran, gender equality
  • Gholamreza Jamshidiha, Maryam Sha’Ban * Pages 967-994
    Introduction
    The present study, based on the resistance discourse of inverted Orientalism, seeks to provide an understanding of the indigenous conditions of Iranian society in relation to the rights of the child. The purpose of this study is to compare the rights of the child in six different areas: "1) Laws and regulations in Iran; 2) Internal policies in three areas of governance, government and bureaucracy; 3) Iranian civil society; 4) Policies of the international community (international); 5) The religion of Islam; 6) Policies of the Islamic world as the main areas of determining the nature of children's rights. This comparison is to identify and extract the advantages and strengths of children's rights in Islam over other areas of children's rights. The questions of the present study are "Similarities and general differences in the rights of the child in the six different areas of law and regulation in Iran; Internal policies in three areas of governance, government and bureaucracy; Iranian civil society; Policies of the international community (international); The religion of Islam; the policies of the Islamic world; and " the positive points and advantages of children's rights in Islam over other areas". 
    Method
    By exploratory analysis, the six domestic and foreign areas that are the basis of the definition of children's rights in Iran are based on Iranian laws and regulations; Internal policies in three areas of governance, government and bureaucracy; Iranian civil society; Policies of the International Community (International); and The religion of Islam. According to the foundation, we have identified the policies of the Islamic world and then analyzed them with the method of qualitative content analysis.
    Results and discussion
    Due to its traditional and Islamic conditions, Iranian society considers the child within the family and under the guardianship of parents or guardians to support the child with the priority of collective interests in the family and society. According to this principle, the child has the right to life in the family, even if it is not more than fertilization. The observance of this right is something beyond generation and beyond history, which includes previous generations. The child has the right to independence, non-colonialism and non-sanction in a larger or more structured community such as society.
    Conclusion
    Children of Islamic societies, including Iran, need the rights that are not considered by the central societies like the Convention on the Rights of the Child as the dominant global sources, as if the rights of the child presented in global sources, separate reading and miles. It is far from the social and cultural contexts of the surrounding communities (including Islamic and Iranian). This issue requires the attention and action of the surrounding communities in order to provide an "indigenous structure of child rights."
    Keywords: Child Rights, Inverted Orientalism, Center-Periphery Communities, localism, Iranian Islamic Child Rights
  • Pezhman Barkhordari *, Seyed Hossien Serajzadeh, Abdolmohammad Kazemipur Pages 995-1026
    Introduction
    Religious identity has been one of the most important aspects of shaping the social identity of individuals and social groups in Iran, and such a major and fundamental force has historically played a role in social changes in Iran. Moreover, religious identity is not a closed and homogeneous whole and has a variety of dimensions and components. On the other hand, the media, especially cinema and television, are not always detached from their social and political space, so they represent the content of their message, influenced by the dominant socio-political discourses, in a special way, highlighting a number of dimensions and ignoring others.
    Method
    This study seeks to study how different religiosity dimensions of social classes are represented in post-revolutionary Iranian cinema. The dimensions of religiosity considered in the present study are derived from the Glock and Stark's model of religiosity, as well as the implications of the class is based on Pierre Bourdieu's theory of distinction in which, the composition and volume of various capitals are involved in the class formation. Finally, these two theoretical levels are analyzed in the context of Stuart Hall's constructivist approach to representation. Out of the dozens of movies in Iranian cinema, two levels of theoretical and typical sampling was conducted and finally two film in each decade that were theoretically more closely aligned with the research criteria were selected and analyzed. The films included: Pure Repentance (1983), Two Blind Eyes (1984), from Karkheh to Rhein (1991), Smell of Camphor, Scent of Jasmine (2000), A House Built on Water (2001), Book of Law (2008), Scandal (2012) and Sensitive Class (2013). These films have been examined by John Fisk's Critical Semiotics at three levels of "reality, representation, and ideology".
    Results and discussion
    Finally, the combination and integration of the first two levels is represented in the last level, i.e., ideology. Critical semiotics of films have also shown that the representation of the five dimensions of religiosity of each social class, influenced by the discourses of each decade, has undergone significant changes, including reduction in the religiosity dimensions of the lower class, especially emotional dimension, compared to the 1960s, the relative stability of the dimensions of middle-class religiosity from the 1970s onwards, and the growing emphasis on the ritual dimension of religiosity of the upper class in the last decade. Such changes and fluctuations in the representation system of cinema itself have been affected by changes in the discourses that govern each decade.
    Conclusion
    The results of this study, on the other hand, confirmed that cinema, based on its representative nature, show the complex relations between the fundamental forces in Iranian society, namely religiosity and class relations, through the lens of cinema. It is important to note, however, that in comparison with literature of the study, which considers "religious cinema" to be stable in contrast to current trends in society, or without considering class formations, or impose single discourse on "Religious subjects", this study shows that despite the existence of specific political, social and economic discourses in each decade, such discourses do not affect the dimensions of religiosity of all classes in a similar and integrated way, moreover, representation of the dimensions of religiosity of different social classes have had significant fluctuations and changes.
    Keywords: Critical semiotics, Social classes, Religiosity, Representation, iranian cinema
  • Younes Akbari *, Hossain Mirzaie, Abouali Vedadhir Pages 1027-1052
    Introduction
    by saying the word of interest, the first thing that comes to mind immediately is economic interest and this is while different fields of life have their own interests which are not necessarily economic interests.
    Method
    the present study uses the documentary method to investigate the diversity of levels and non-economic meanings of the concept of interest from the perspective of sociologists and intends to provide for researchers a conceptual tool for explaining social phenomena by emphasizing Bourdieu's understanding of interest.
    Results and discussion
    This study shows that Alexis De Tocqueville, Marx Weber, Gustav Ratzenhofer, Albion Small, Edward Alsworth Ross, George Simmel And James Coleman have used profit in its micro and individual form. However, there is a difference between these thinkers regarding the concept of interest and that of Tocqueville, Weber, Coleman and Simmel. The later have considered the concept of interest as a social element and have used it in the analysis of relations between people in society. But Ratzenhofer, Small, And Ross have a pre-social understanding of the concept of interest, and see it as an element that shapes society, not a factor through which relationships between individuals in society can be analyzed. The study also suggests that thinkers such as karl Marx, Arthur Bentley, And Pierre Bourdieu used interest collectively. However, with a deeper look at the empirical application of the theories of the above thinkers in relation to the concept of interest, it may be said that Marx's sociological view of the concept of interest in the form of class interests, although has a sociological burden and does not consider interest specific to the individual. It considers the economic meaning of interest for a group of people of the same class and in a way closes the way for thinking and reflecting on other various and non-economic forms of interest. Bentley's view leads to the tautology by uniting the interest and the road group and for this reason; the possibility of experimental application and testability is limited.
    Conclusion
    In his analysis, Bourdieu showed that the fields of academia, art, etc., have interests that are not necessarily economic interests and are governed by rules other than those of the world of economics. The process of segregation of social worlds, each of which has its own interests or spheres of power, requires that social researchers be equipped with a conceptual and theoretical tool to discover the interests, the relationships between field actors, and the internal rules of these social fields. This conceptual tool, in addition to being more in line with social reality, unlike the Marxist concept of benefit, is not limited to the economic and possibly political sense, and can also discover non-economic interests that govern human life and measure people's relationships with these types of non-economic benefits in addition to the above, the advantage of Bourdieu's understanding of interest over Bentley's understanding is that it is free from the flaws of tautology. And he does not equate the benefit with the field and states that the interest belongs to the field and not the field itself. It also has this advantage over micro-level theorists. In addition to the micro level (at the level of family and group friendship, etc.), it also has the ability to be applied at the macro and collective level. With these interpretations, the author believes that Bourdieu's sociological application of the concept of interest can be a practical tool for social science researchers to understand the social world.
    Keywords: sociology, Interest, Economy, field, Bourdieu